Successful unit-based teams take on multiple goals on the Value Compass, get results and move on. But focusing on the right goals—and not getting lost in the process—can be a challenge. Fresno Medical Center, which reports the highest percentage of high-performing UBTs in all of Kaiser Permanente, has developed tools to help teams set priorities. The prioritization matrix, a tool used in performance improvement, is part of a four-step process.

•   Step 1: Identify improvement opportunities with the team. Develop ideas with the help of the team sponsors or UBT consultants, and pay special attention to your Performance Sharing Program (PSP) goals.

•   Step 2: Use the Project Prioritization Matrix to determine project priority.

•   Step 3: Enter project data into UBT Tracker.

•   Step 4: Share project information with the UBT consultant or union partnership representative, who can connect the team with other resources, including “affinity groups” working on similar goals.

“It’s a very simple process that helps teams focus and know why they’re doing what they’re doing,” says Fresno’s Navneet Maan, a UBT consultant.  

“Teams can work through this process during their regular meetings,” she adds. “The project selection becomes a more transparent process, and the tool helps align their work with regional goals that will make a difference to members and patients.”

I am a big proponent of the team approach to medicine. That’s why I am an active participant of my department’s unit-based team.

As the physician co-lead for the Pediatrics unit-based team, I participate in the UBT meetings both to give and to receive ideas. Ideally, a physician brings to a UBT the vision on how to work together to provide the best possible patient care, support for the management co-lead, and the willingness and openness to listen to what other people have to say. 

According to Dr. Atul Gawande, noted author and surgeon, it used to be that doctors were trained to be cowboys. They worked alone and saved the day. In today’s world, what people really need are pit crews, teams of people where everyone’s function is vital to the overall success of the enterprise. Medicine is no longer an individual endeavor—it has grown so complex and multifaceted that no physician can know everything. So we need to foster the team approach to give our patients the best possible care. 

When I first came to Kaiser nearly 10 years ago, the thing I heard that really stuck with me was the KP Service Quality credo: “Our cause is health. Our passion is service. We’re here to make lives better.” I immediately connected with it and have used it to filter everything I do. 

In other words, I always ask myself: Does what we are doing support our cause, passion and goal? If it does, then it’s usually worth doing. 

Advice to other physicians  

• Say "thank you" and say "please." Really go out of your way to appreciate someone who comes up with an idea that has made your life easier. And do it publicly.
• Make time for daily huddles with your staff.
• Create an environment in which people feel free to share their ideas. One of the worst forms of waste is unused creativity.
• Give people the benefit of the doubt; pause and reflect when you feel yourself getting upset.
• Think outside the box. Go to staff members who aren’t at the nursing station to help out when needed. This gives the whole team a sense of ownership over patient care. 

Bottom line? Being a leader isn’t just about being in charge. Just because you’re a physician doesn’t mean you have to spearhead all of the work. If you really want to make a difference or a change, you have to include the entire staff. The work will get done better, faster and easier if we work together. And if you believe in the work that you are doing, then teamwork is a natural expression of patient care.

Imagine developing a severe cough and teeth-chattering chills. You want to be seen by a doctor but no one really understands you: Not the call center operator with whom you try to make an appointment; not the receptionist who checks you in; not the medical assistant who takes your temperature and blood pressure. Not even the doctor who speaks quickly and uses complicated medical terms.

“When you come in for medical care, it’s already like a foreign land,” says Kathleen Kearney, the manager and the UBT co-lead for the Obstetrics and Gynecology department at San Jose Medical Center.  “If you don’t speak English, it can be downright frightening.”

Giving patients better access

Kaiser Permanente has long been committed to providing language access in the form of interpretive services for its non-English speaking members. The Ob/Gyn unit-based team in San Jose has taken the additional step of creating a Spanish-speaking module, a sort of one-stop shop for Spanish-speaking patients.

The idea for the module came from Joseph Derrough, MD, who recognized that good patient care involves more than just the patient and the physician in the exam room. It includes each interaction, from making an appointment to checking in and being assigned a room.

“I realized that we had a significant percentage of patients who only spoke Spanish, and we could do better service to them by providing linguistic and culturally competent care,” Dr. Derrough says. “We had staff that spoke Spanish, but they weren’t all in the same place. My vision was that we could create a clinic module where, from registration to examination, the patient was spoken to in her own language.”

Making it happen

The unit-based team made it happen.

“From the time they walk in the door, every patient should receive the same level of care regardless of the language they speak,” says Glenda Morrison, a medical assistant, SEIU UHW chief shop steward and the UBT co-lead.

But in the beginning, the frontline staff members, including Morrison, were skeptical.

“Since we were already serving Spanish-speaking patients in our clinic, the question we were asking was, ‘Why is this needed?’ ” Morrison says.

But a visit to the Spanish-speaking Medicine module at the Santa Clara campus made them believers. That module has been in place for five years.

“When I saw it in action, a light went off—and I realized that by not speaking to our Spanish-speaking members in their own language, we weren’t providing them with the same care as we were our English-speaking members,” Morrison says.

Overcoming obstacles

Once the team decided to take on the project, it faced some challenges. Offices had to be moved and medical assistants had to be reassigned.

“We had a lot of meetings and a lot of nervous people,” Morrison says.

But again, the Santa Clara example eased fears: “Once they saw how it worked in Santa Clara, we got by-in from the staff and it was easier,” Kearney says.

The module, which opened Sept. 29, includes signage and literature in Spanish. The staff members, from the receptionists and medical assistants to the doctors, are fluent Spanish speakers.  Word about the new module went out through Spanish-speaking television news and newspaper reports. And there was a grand opening.

It’s going well so far, Kearny says, noting that “we have three Spanish-speaking providers each day, and they have appointment capacity for about 20 patients.”

Next steps

Now, the team is looking for ways to quantify the benefits of the new module. It’s hoping to be able to collect patient satisfaction data specifically from Spanish-speaking members to assess the impact, Kearney says.

“If it shows success, we’ll pass the idea on to other teams,” she says.

Meanwhile, the unit is looking at how it can provide culturally competent care for its other monolingual patients.

“We don’t what a certain group to feel singled out,” Morrison says. “We just want them to feel comfortable.”

When you get to the leadership level it’s easy to become disconnected and to forget that where the rubber meets the road is at the front line. Sponsoring a unit-based team helps me stay connected—and that helps me be a better manager.

Staying connected

As a sponsor for the Medical Secretaries and Scanning Center, I help the teams see where they fit in the bigger picture—and they help me see the challenges that teams face every day.

I check in with the teams and their co-leaders regularly, make sure they’re accomplishing their goals and doing work that meets regional and national goals. They have their own ideas for improving department operations and doing their own small tests of change. I help them think strategically about how they can impact the region and Kaiser Permanente as a whole.  

There will always be the manager-employee relationship, but when you walk into a UBT meeting, you leave the hierarchy at the door. To build credibility, everyone on the UBT must have an equal voice at the table. I believe in the partnership and, yes, there are a few times when a manager shoulders the responsibility and has to make decisions about regulatory compliance issues, regional strategic direction and planning, scope of practice discussions about licensures and policies, and personnel management. But there are a lot of other decisions that staff can be a part of making in a group setting, and getting buy-in from the folks who do the work makes all the difference in the world.

Removing obstacles

Because I’m in a leadership role, it is important that I help the teams overcome barriers. If they need help understanding a goal, metric or budget, I can gather the information and package it in a way that is most helpful to the team.  When I started working with these teams in 2007, they were already doing good work despite some major obstacles. The chartroom transitioned to the scanning center, and the medical secretaries had a lot of manager and staff turnover, and had difficulty meeting performance metrics. Now both teams are high functioning. They have accomplished so much in the last two years.

So to other sponsors I say, don’t be afraid to jump in. It’s so rewarding to see your teams grow. If we are going to improve performance, we’ll need engagement at all levels of the organization, and the UBT process allows that to happen.